Product Hunt vs Indie Hackers vs Hacker News

Quick answer: Use Product Hunt for a polished product-discovery launch, Indie Hackers for founder-to-founder discussion and progress context, and Hacker News Show HN when people can try something technically interesting or novel. They are not interchangeable posting channels; adapt the story, proof and participation to each community.

The best platform depends on who should care and what you can contribute. Posting identical copy across all three ignores the culture that gives each platform value.

Comparison at a glance

Rules and product mechanics change. Review official or current community guidance before posting.

Product Hunt: best for a polished discovery moment

Product Hunt provides a structured listing with a tagline, visuals, description, makers and comments. It fits a product with a clean onboarding path and assets ready for a public audience.

Use it when:

• the product is accessible and understandable quickly;
• visual presentation helps explain it;
• you can support a concentrated traffic window;
• a permanent launch profile is useful for future research.

Do not expect: ranking to prove product-market fit. Measure activation and repeat use. Prepare with the Product Hunt launch checklist.

Indie Hackers: best for context and peer learning

Indie Hackers is oriented around the experience of building and growing independent products. A useful post explains decisions, numbers with context, failed experiments, trade-offs or a problem other founders can discuss.

Use it when:

• the founder story teaches something specific;
• you want ongoing peer relationships;
• feedback from other builders is relevant;
• you can participate beyond your own launch thread.

Avoid: a press release disguised as a lesson. If the post would not help without the product link, deepen the content.

Hacker News Show HN: best for something tryable and technically interesting

The official Show HN guidelines emphasize that users should be able to try what you made and that the post should be direct. Some products are not a fit, particularly if they cannot be accessed or meaningfully demonstrated.

Use it when:

• the product has technical, novel or intellectually interesting substance;
• readers can try it without a sales process;
• you can answer implementation and product questions candidly;
• the title can state plainly what the product does.

Avoid: growth-hacking the submission, hiding material limitations or using marketing-heavy language. Critical comments are part of the value.

Use different narratives

Suppose you built an automated screenshot API:

Product Hunt

Lead with the outcome, visual examples, supported workflows and polished gallery.

Indie Hackers

Explain why you chose a screenshot API market, how you found early users, infrastructure trade-offs and actual launch lessons.

Hacker News

Let people try it. Explain rendering architecture, difficult browser edge cases or a novel technical decision without turning the post into documentation theater.

The product is the same; the contribution is different.

A sensible launch sequence

1. Private customers validate the workflow.
2. Indie Hackers or a niche founder community helps sharpen the story.
3. Hacker News fits if the product is tryable and technically relevant.
4. Product Hunt creates a polished, broader discovery moment.
5. Directories create additional durable paths.

The order can change. The principle is to let each release produce evidence for the next. Read how to launch SaaS without an audience and where to launch your SaaS for a wider plan.

What to measure by platform

Avoid comparing only impressions or votes. Source cohorts can behave differently over the following weeks.

Community participation rules

• Read current rules and recent successful discussions.
• Disclose your relationship to the product.
• Do not coordinate fake engagement or use multiple accounts.
• Give a complete answer before linking to your product.
• Accept criticism and correct factual errors.
• Do not repost the same promotion repeatedly.
• Protect customer data when sharing metrics or stories.

Use startup directories for distribution for systematic tracking beyond these communities.

Frequently asked questions

Which platform sends the most traffic?

It varies by product, timing and audience. Large traffic is not automatically valuable. Compare qualified activation and retention using your own source data.

Can I launch on all three?

Yes, if the product fits and each post contributes appropriately. Stagger the posts and rewrite the narrative for the community.

Is Hacker News only for developer tools?

No, but Show HN performs best when people can try something and the audience can engage with the substance. Technical or novel products often fit naturally.

Is Indie Hackers a Product Hunt alternative?

Partly, but it serves a different job. Indie Hackers is more discussion- and journey-oriented; Product Hunt is structured around product discovery and launch pages.

Official and primary sources

• Product Hunt launch guide
• Hacker News Show HN guidelines
• Indie Hackers